Chock to chock
by Dale Nielsen
Crosswinds are still taking their toll during take-offs and landings.
It appears pilots are not paying enough attention to winds until drift or
weathercocking becomes significant. Then it is often too late.
The Cessna 150 pilot was taking off on runway 35 at the Arborg, MB airport with
the wind gusting from the northwest when the aircraft drifted right and the
right main tire entered a snow drift. The pilot rejected the takeoff, the
aircraft tipped over and came to rest on its nose and right wing.
The pilot of a Stinson 108 commenced a takeoff on a narrow runway with a left
crosswind component. The aircraft began to weathercock into wind and the pilot
corrected with right rudder and brake. The aircraft continued left into a snow
bank at the edge of the runway and nosed over.
The pilot of a Piper PA 22-135 TriPacer modified to a tail wheel configuration
was attempting to takeoff with a light crosswind when it veered to the left. The
aircraft departed the runway, encountered soft ground and nosed over.
While attempting a crosswind landing on runway 13 at Tisdale, SK the pilot of a
Cessna 170B lost control of the aircraft. The aircraft departed the right side
of the runway, resulting in damage to the left wing, left landing gear and the
propeller. The wind was from 200 degrees at five to seven knots.
The Cessna 177B Cardinal pilot was operating out of his farm strip with a five
knot, 90 degree crosswind. On landing, the aircraft drifted to the side of the
runway in spite of hard braking, and ran into hard crusted snow. The nose gear
failed and the aircraft came to rest of the side of the strip.
The Bellanca 1731A pilot observed the wind was gusting from the right while on
the final approach to runway 20 at Southend, SK. After landing, the pilot was
unable to keep the aircraft on the runway with ailerons and rudder. The aircraft
departed the left side of the runway. The right wing, landing gear and propeller
sustained considerable damage.
We are too complacent about winds. Before taking off, we check the wind to
determine the appropriate runway and then we often don't give it another thought
until the aircraft starts to weathercock into the wind or drift off the
centerline. Most of the time the wind is fairly light and we are able to apply
the correct control inputs in time to get airborne safely. Likely we learned
nothing from the incident.
The last thing we should do before taking to the runway is to assess the wind
one more time. We must begin the take-off roll with the correct aileron and
rudder inputs, and then adjust these inputs as required to keep the aircraft on
the center line.
This is especially important when attempting soft field takeoffs, as the C-150
pilot above discovered. The nose high attitude blocks our forward view of the
runway making it more difficult to see the effect of a crosswind. If we are not
paying adequate attention to drift, we won't see it until it is too late.
Complacency during take-off in a conventional gear (tail wheel) aircraft is
dangerous as the Stinson 108 and PA 22-135 pilots discovered. Slipstream effect,
torque, and gyroscopic effect require concentration to control as the tail is
lifted off the runway. Any crosswind, no matter how light, will have a
significant effect on that big sail in the rear, and the aircraft will want to
weathercock. This tendency has to be corrected immediately. If we are not
prepared for the crosswind, we may not notice the swing into wind in time to
correct for it.
Accidents involving crosswinds on landing are even more common. Pilots usually
fly the final approach with correct aileron and rudders inputs to maintain the
center of the runway. They usually hold those inputs throughout the flare for
landing. We must remember however, that as the aircraft slows down, the
crosswind has more effect on the aircraft. The aileron and rudder inputs must be
progressively increased. We must continue to increase the aileron and rudder
inputs after the main wheels touch down so that by the time the nose wheel
touches down we may have full aileron into the wind, which is where it should be
for taxi. We have a tendency to relax when the main wheels touch the ground and
mistakenly return the ailerons to neutral. Even a fairly light crosswind can
still cause weathercocking or drift off the runway.
Soft and short field landings are particularly susceptible to unnoticed
weathercocking or drift, as the pilot is concentrating on the soft or short
field technique.
Conventional gear aircraft are even more susceptible to crosswinds on landing.
The C-170 pilot discovered that even a light crosswind could give him the ride
of his life.
A three-point landing in a conventional gear aircraft has a very nose high
attitude, making it difficult to see drift occurring until it is pronounced.
Cues other than forward vision must be used to eliminate drift and to notice
immediately if the tail is beginning to swing. It doesn't take much of a swing
before the aircraft is in an uncontrollable ground loop. The advantage of this
method of landing is the tail can be pinned immediately with aft elevator
control to reduce the tendency to swing and to help with the tail wheel
steering.
Many tail dragger pilots prefer a wheel landing in a crosswind as this nose
attitude allows for better forward visibility and easier assessment of drift and
weathercocking. Problems arise however, as the tail is lowered. Pilots have to
be aware that rudder and into wind aileron inputs have to be increased
significantly as the tail is being lowered to avoid weathercocking. They must
correct for the slightest indication of the tail beginning to swing and they
must pin the tail wheel with full aft elevator input as quickly as possible.
Winds are part of takeoffs and landings. Winds are often variable and
unpredictable. Winds should never be taken for granted. If we don't pay enough
attention to the wind, we may end up with bent metal and bent pride.
Dale Nielsen is an ex-Armed Forces pilot, charter pilot and air service operator. He freelances as a corporate pilot and Class 1 flying instructor from his home in Winlaw, B.C.
Back to Safety Bulletin Page