We all know about the regulation that stipulates that we not fly above 10,000
feet for more than 30 minutes or above 13,000 feet at all, unless we are
breathing on board oxygen. Few of us pay enough attention to this regulation.
Last month’s column described a Mooney pilot flying under VFR OTT flight rules
who had to climb to 15,000 feet to remain clear of cloud. The report this
description was taken from did not say how long this pilot had to remain at
15,000 before he was vectored to VFR conditions north of Winnipeg, but it had to
have been at least 15 minutes, and more likely was considerably longer.
The pilot of a Seneca 2 filed IFR at 12,000 feet direct from Castlegar to Prince
George, B.C. The weather was unsuitable for VFR in the Castlegar area, but was
expected to improve to VFR conditions about 100 miles north. The pilot did not
have access to oxygen, but reasoned that he would be able to cancel his IFR
clearance and descend to VFR conditions within 30 minutes. The forecast was
wrong. The cloud did not clear to VFR conditions, and after one hour of flight,
and the pilot was forced to climb to 14,000 feet to comply with IFR minimum en
route altitudes. He was airborne for one and one half hours above 10,000 feet,
including 30 minutes above 13,000 feet, before he was able to descend to below
10,000 feet in VFR conditions. The pilot later reported feeling quite tired
before he was able to make the descent.
Pilots in British Columbia regularly fly for periods of longer than 30 minutes
above 10,000 feet to maintain terrain clearance while flying above the mountains
on direct routes between airports. They get away with it once and think the
regulation has no basis, at least for them.
All of these pilots were risking their lives, and the lives of any passengers
who were relying on them.
Hypoxia is very insidious. It creeps up on us slowly. Our brains and our eyes
use about 70 per cent of the oxygen we consume. When we become even slightly
oxygen deprived, our brain functions begin to slow down and we begin to feel a
little tired. We do not notice it, but our visual acuity also decreases. As
hypoxia progresses we may feel a dull headache and a little sleepy. Eventually
we would fall asleep.
Military organizations around the world use high altitude chambers to train
pilots how to cope with a sudden loss of pressurization. The chamber operators
demonstrate to pilots the effects of hypoxia by asking them to remove their
oxygen masks and attempt simple mental arithmetic problems or to try to write
something. They prove over and over again that even simple tasks become
impossible when the pilots become hypoxic, which occurs within a few minutes of
oxygen mask removal. Granted, the altitudes they are working with are in the
30,000-foot range, but hypoxia can affect us even at altitudes below 10,000
feet.
All of us react to oxygen deprivation at slightly different rates, and our
individual reaction rate may vary according to various factors, such as age,
fitness, health, fatigue, nutrition and whether we smoke.
Age and fitness often go together. The more fit we are, the better we are able
to process the oxygen we consume, and generally we are more alert. Often, as we
age, we become somewhat less fit.
Even minor health problems cause us to become fatigued more quickly. Fatigue
causes us to be less alert and less aware that changes are occurring to us
physically and mentally. Poor, or inadequate, nutrition also reduces our level
of fitness and alertness.
Smoking increases the levels of carbon dioxide in our blood and reduces lung
capacity. This reduces our ability to efficiently process oxygen and will hasten
the onset of hypoxia.
Add a few of these factors together and maybe on a given day we wouldn’t be
capable of flying above 10,000 feet at all, or even well below 10,000 feet for
any length of time without becoming hypoxic.
If hypoxia reduces and then renders impossible our ability to manipulate numbers
or write, it obviously reduces our ability to analyze situations and make
decisions, and it increases the risk of disorientation. The pilots in the
situations described earlier in this column were lucky. The Seneca 2 pilot
admitted o feeling ‘quite tired.’ He was somewhat hypoxic, and it is likely
the Mooney pilot was as well. We don’t know about the countless VFR pilots who
stayed at altitude too long, but likely many of them were a little hypoxic as
well.
Most flights are relatively routine and do not require intense concentration, or
rapid and difficult decisions, so we may get away with slight hypoxia as did the
pilots mentioned. When things go wrong, anxiety and excitement increase and we
may begin to breathe more rapidly and possibly hyperventilate. Hyperventilation
is rapid, shallow breathing that eliminates more carbon dioxide in the blood
than normal, which causes a change in the acidity of the blood, which in turn
causes the blood vessels to the brain to constrict, reducing blood flow, and
therefore oxygen supply. This of course would increase the rate of hypoxia. The
symptoms of hyperventilation are dizziness, a feeling of coldness, a sensation
of a tight band around the head, and a sensation of pins and needles in the
hands and feet.
Pilots, over the years, do build some tolerance for altitude. How much tolerance
we build is difficult to say, but we do become complacent to the effects of
hypoxia. Non-pilots are more susceptible to the effects of altitude. If
passengers begin complaining of being tired or of headaches, they are likely
becoming hypoxic. We should descend to assist them, and we should descend to
protect all of us, we might be soon hypoxic as well.
We can never be certain that everything will go right. By placing ourselves in
situations where we may reduce our level of awareness and decision making
capability; we are endangering our lives and the lives of our passengers. The
rules covering altitudes and the use of oxygen were designed for sound medical
reasons. Some days we may feel super human, but remember it is only a feeling.
Avoid that sleepy sensation while flying.
Dale Nielsen is an ex-Armed Forces pilot, charter pilot and air service operator. He lives in Richmond B.C. where he freelances as an aerial photography pilot and Class 1 flying instructor. Nielsen is also the author of five flight training manuals published by Canuck West Holdings.
Back to Safety Bulletin Page